Japan Prelim GDP q/q on CHFJPY: 4/4 big-miss DOWN at 1h ONLY — same delayed lock-in as yesterday's EURJPY, and the SHALLOWEST 1h magnitude (-6.45p) in the whole JPY GDP cross-family. Seventh and FINAL pair, closes the 7-pair family with a two-tier structure.
64 non-contaminated Japan Prelim GDP q/q releases on CHFJPY. Big_miss median deepens monotonically -4.25p → -5.80p → -6.45p through 1h and locks into full 4/4 DOWN unanimity only at 1h— same delayed pattern as yesterday’s EURJPY. The 1h magnitude -6.45p is the SHALLOWESTin the entire 7-pair family (half of GBPJPY’s -13.45p), because CHF competes with JPY for safe-haven flow more strongly than any other base currency in the family.
Seventh and final pair, closing the JPY Prelim GDP cross-family after USDJPY, AUDJPY, NZDJPY, CADJPY, GBPJPY, and EURJPY. The family divides cleanly into two tiers: five high-beta risk-currency bases (USD/AUD/NZD/CAD/GBP) lock in the safe-haven flip at 15m and average -12.24p at 1h; two safe-haven-adjacent bases (EUR/CHF) delay lock-in to 1h and average -8.53p at 1h. CHFJPY sits at the deepest end of Tier 2 — the shallowest 1h magnitude in the whole family — because CHF competes with JPY for safe-haven flow more strongly than EUR does.

Delayed safe-haven lock-in — the shallowest 1h in the family
| Window | big_miss n | big_miss med | big_miss pct_up | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1m | 4 | -0.35p | 25.0% (1/4) | 2014-11-16 flipper mixed |
| 5m | 4 | -1.60p | 50.0% (2/4) | flipper briefly rolls over then bounces |
| 15m | 4 | -4.25p | 25.0% (1/4) | BREAKS UNANIMITY — 2014-11-16 back at +4.00p |
| 30m | 4 | -5.80p | 25.0% (1/4) | still 3/4 down; flipper still +3.40p |
| 1h | 4 | -6.45p | 0.0% (0/4) | FULL 4/4 UNANIMITY — SHALLOWEST 1h in family |
| 4h | 4 | -1.55p | 50.0% (2/4) | REVERTS — 2014-11-16 at -50.80p pulls median |
The flipper print — 2014-11-16 recession confirmation on CHFJPY
| Release | Actual | Consensus | z | 15m move | Context |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014-02-16 | +0.3% | +0.7% | -1.67 | -9.60p | Abenomics year-1; straight down |
| 2014-11-16 | -0.4% | +0.5% | -3.45 | +4.00p | THE FLIPPER — largest 15m positive of any Tier 2 pair on this print |
| 2020-02-16 | -1.6% | -1.0% | -2.41 | -5.80p | pre-COVID slowdown; sign holds |
| 2021-11-14 | -0.8% | -0.2% | -1.55 | -2.70p | Delta-variant Japan; shallow but sign holds |
The 2014-11-16 print is the family’s pedagogic gem. Its 15m behavior traces exactly where each base currency sits on the risk-off spectrum: -1.30p on GBPJPY (Tier 1 high-β, base sold), -1.40p on CADJPY (Tier 1, oil), strongly negative on USDJPY/AUDJPY/NZDJPY (Tier 1), +2.20p on EURJPY (Tier 2 moderate), and +4.00p on CHFJPY (Tier 2 deepest — CHF strongest safe-haven competitor). The flipper persists on CHFJPY through 30m (+3.40p) and only rolls over at 1h to -6.30p. By 4h it is -50.80p — the sign eventually catches the fundamentals, but the first 30 minutes belong to CHF-bid competition.
Full 7-pair JPY Prelim GDP cross-family — closer table
| Pair | Tier | 15m pct_up | Lock-in | 1h median | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GBPJPY | 1 high-β | 0.0% | 15m | -13.45p | highest-β base sold in risk-off |
| USDJPY | 1 high-β | 0.0% | 15m | -13.25p | USD sold in risk-off |
| AUDJPY | 1 high-β | 0.0% | 15m | -13.25p | AUD sold in risk-off |
| NZDJPY | 1 high-β | 0.0% | 15m | -11.70p | NZD sold in risk-off |
| EURJPY | 2 sh-adj | 25.0% | 1h | -10.60p | EUR mildly bid in risk-off — partial cancel |
| CADJPY | 1 high-β | 0.0% | 15m | -8.55p | CAD sold in risk-off, oil reattach at 4h |
| CHFJPY | 2 sh-adj | 25.0% | 1h | -6.45p | CHF strongly bid in risk-off — shallowest peak |
Five Tier 1 pairs average -12.24p at 1h; two Tier 2 pairs average -8.53p at 1h — 30% shallower. The base-currency safe-haven-competitiveness explains the pair-level magnitude ordering. The 4h behavior further splits the family: CADJPY (oil reattach) and CHFJPY (CHF competition persists) both revert to 2/4, but CHFJPY’s single-print 4h outlier (2014-11-16 -50.80p) is the second-deepest 4h reading in the family after CADJPY’s -60.7p on the same print.
Bucket-boundary sign inversion at 15m — same as all 6 siblings
| Bucket | n | Median 15m | Pct-up 15m | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| big_miss | 4 | -4.25p | 25.0% | safe-haven flip PARTIAL: 3/4 down (delayed to 1h) |
| small_miss | 16 | +5.45p | 68.75% | textbook JPY-weakens on soft data → CHFJPY up 11/16 |
| in_line | 23 | -1.00p | 43.48% | mixed |
| small_beat | 16 | -1.35p | 50.00% | essentially flat |
| big_beat | 5 | -0.80p | 40.00% | small sample; flat |
The sign STILL flips at the small_miss → big_miss boundary on CHFJPY (11/16 UP → 1/4 UP is a large jump), with only 3-of-4 unanimity at 15m instead of 4-of-4. Every one of the 7 crosses shares this threshold jump — the safe-haven flip is a real bucket-boundary effect on Japan GDP big-misses, regardless of which base currency the pair is quoted in. Only the SPEED of onset (Tier 1 vs Tier 2) and the PEAK magnitude (which shrinks with the base’s own safe-haven demand) vary across pairs.
Verification note and small-sample caveat
All numbers verified against live /api/v1/news-impact/stats and /api/v1/news-impact/releases on 2026-09-10 across all 6 windows. Chart via pnpm insights:chartCLI. Sample: 64 non-contaminated Japan Prelim GDP q/q releases. Big_miss n=4 and big_beat n=5 are both far below the tool’s MIN_N=30 threshold and drawn faint — treat this as a small-sample tail-unanimity finding, not a wide-sample effect-size claim. Today’s Stats #41 Clopper-Pearson exact CI post applies the exact binomial interval directly to this CHFJPY 4-of-4 sample: 95% two-sided CI on the true down-rate is [39.76%, 100.00%], which just barely rules out coin-flip. The pedagogic finding here is the TWO-TIER STRUCTURE (fast lock-in on high-beta bases vs delayed lock-in on safe-haven-adjacent bases) and the MAGNITUDE ORDERING (base safe-haven competitiveness determines 1h peak), not the exact per-bucket point estimate.