Japan Prelim GDP q/q on CADJPY: all 4 big-miss prints sent CADJPY DOWN at 15m, 30m, AND 1h — TRIPLE-window big-miss unanimity (12 of 12 zero-flip miss-side moves) — but the aggregate REVERTS at 4h to a 2/4 mixed up-rate. Fourth pair in the JPY Prelim GDP cross-family, and the first whose safe-haven flip fades at 4h.
61 non-contaminated Japan Prelim GDP q/q releases on CADJPY. All 4 big-miss prints (2014-02-16, 2014-11-16, 2020-02-16, 2021-11-14) sent CADJPY DOWN at 15m, 30m, AND 1h — TRIPLE-window big-miss unanimity, 12 of 12 zero-flip miss-side moves. Median walk deepens -3.90p → -7.70p → -8.55p through 1h, then REVERTS to -1.05p at 4h with a 2/4 mixed up-rate.
Fourth pair in the JPY Prelim GDP cross-family after jpy-prelim-gdp-usdjpy-safe-haven (2026-09-05), jpy-prelim-gdp-audjpy-safe-haven (2026-09-06), and jpy-prelim-gdp-nzdjpy-safe-haven (2026-09-07). CADJPY is the FIRST pair in the family whose safe-haven flip FADES at 4h — CAD’s commodity-currency oil-beta reattaches once the initial JPY bid absorbs, and the 4h aggregate flips to mixed. Small_miss goes the OTHER way (68.75% CADJPY UP at 15m — textbook JPY-weakens-on-softer-Japan-data), and big_miss flips to 100% DOWN. Fourth cross-pair replication of the safe-haven paradox threshold.

Triple-window big-miss unanimity, then a 4-h revert
| Window | big_miss n | big_miss med | big_miss pct_up | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1m | 4 | +0.35p | 75.0% (3/4) | sign not flipped yet; 2014-11-16 fake-out +21.2p |
| 5m | 4 | -0.20p | 50.0% (2/4) | sign flipping; 2014-11-16 STILL positive at +27.4p |
| 15m | 4 | -3.90p | 0.0% (0/4) | SAFE-HAVEN FLIP LOCKS IN ← anchor window |
| 30m | 4 | -7.70p | 0.0% (0/4) | deepens |
| 1h | 4 | -8.55p | 0.0% (0/4) | DEEPEST — magnitude peaks at 1h |
| 4h | 4 | -1.05p | 50.0% (2/4) | REVERTS — 2 prints flip positive at 4h |
The 0.0% up-rate at 15m/30m/1h means every one of the 4 big-miss prints stayed below its baseline_px at every window — 12 of 12 zero-flip moves. At 4h the pct_up jumps back to 50.0% (2 of 4 flip positive) and the median softens to just -1.05p. Unlike NZDJPY (which deepened monotonically through 4h), CADJPY rings-out the safe-haven bid by the 4-hour mark and 3 of the 4 individual prints revert toward zero.
Bucket-boundary sign inversion at 15m — the safe-haven threshold
| Bucket | n | Median 15m | Pct-up 15m | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| big_miss | 4 | -3.90p | 0.0% | safe-haven JPY bid DOMINATES: CADJPY down 4/4 |
| small_miss | 16 | +4.75p | 68.75% | textbook currency fundamentals: JPY weakens on soft data → CADJPY up 11/16 |
| in_line | 22 | -0.25p | 45.5% | mixed; essentially flat |
| small_beat | 16 | +0.70p | 50.0% | essentially noise |
| big_beat | 5 | -1.00p | 20.0% | small sample; 4/5 DOWN at 15m — noise, but see 1h below |
The SIGN FLIPS at the small_miss → big_miss boundary — the same threshold that USDJPY, AUDJPY, and NZDJPY posted. Below the big_miss threshold (small_miss, z between roughly -1.5 and 0), Japan GDP works like textbook currency fundamentals: soft Japan data weakens JPY and lifts CADJPY; 11 of 16 small_miss prints went UP. Above the big_miss threshold (z ≤ -1.55), the safe-haven flip dominates: all 4 prints go DOWN. Now confirmed in 4 of the 7 JPY-crosses.
Individual big-miss prints — the 2014-11-16 fake-out-and-explode
| Release | Actual | Consensus | Surprise z | 1m → 4h | Context |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014-02-16 | +0.3% | +0.7% | -1.67 | -7.30p → +3.00p | Abenomics year-1 momentum check; deep at 30m/1h, FLIPS positive at 4h |
| 2014-11-16 | -0.4% | +0.5% | -3.45 | +21.20p → -60.70p | recession confirmation; fake-out +27.4p at 5m, FLIPS at 15m, DEEPENS 43× by 4h — BoJ Halloween QQE weekend follows |
| 2020-02-16 | -1.6% | -1.0% | -2.41 | +0.10p → +6.00p | pre-COVID Japan slowdown; deep at 15m/30m/1h, FLIPS positive at 4h |
| 2021-11-14 | -0.8% | -0.2% | -1.55 | +0.60p → -5.10p | Delta-variant Japan outbreak; shallow but sign holds |
The 2014-11-16 print is the pedagogic gem for the family. It fake-broke UP intraday to +21.2p at 1m and STILL positive at +27.4p at 5m (the biggest 1m-and-5m positive of any big-miss print in the family — CAD oil-beta briefly overwhelmed the JPY safe-haven bid), then FULL FLIPPED at 15m to -1.4p, DEEPENED steadily through 30m/1h/2h, and ended at -60.70p at 4h as the BoJ Halloween QQE weekend approached (announced the following Friday). Three of the four prints revert at 4h (this one, 2020-02-16, and 2014-02-16 all end within +6p or so of zero, or in the 2014-11-16 case DEEPEN massively). The median-of-4 washes to just -1.05p because two flip positive and one stays at -5.1p.
Cross-pair 4-h behaviour ordering — a base-leg factor gradient
| Pair | 15m med | 1h med | 4h med | 4h up-rate | 4h pattern |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| USDJPY | -13p | -13p | -11p | 0.0% | hold — deep USD liquidity absorbs at fair value |
| NZDJPY | -8.25p | -11.70p | -12.85p | 0.0% | monotonic-deepen — thinnest base, slowest re-attach |
| AUDJPY | -9p | -13.3p | -4.2p | 25.0% | peak-and-fade — moderate re-attach |
| CADJPY | -3.90p | -8.55p | -1.05p | 50.0% | peak-and-REVERT — CAD reattaches fast to oil-beta |
Four different 4-h patterns from four different base legs on the SAME 4-print big-miss set. USDJPY sits closest to the safe-haven flow itself and holds. NZDJPY is thinnest and slowest to re-attach, so the bid keeps propagating and the median deepens. AUDJPY partially fades. CADJPY reverts entirely — CAD tracks OIL more than it tracks JPY-safe-haven, so once the initial JPY bid absorbs by 1h, CAD’s factor loading reattaches to WTI/Brent and US macro, and JPY-safe-haven dissipates. The 4-h up-rate walks 0.0% → 0.0% → 25.0% → 50.0% across the four pairs and is exactly the “how quickly does base-leg currency return to its own factor loadings” ordering.
Cross-family notes
Fourth pair in the JPY Prelim GDP cross-family. Three JPY-crosses remain to close the arc: GBPJPY (4/4 at 15m/30m/1h, 3/4 at 4h in planning verification), EURJPY (3/4 at 15m/30m, 4/4 at 1h, 2/4 at 4h), and CHFJPY (3/4 at 15m/30m, 4/4 at 1h, 2/4 at 4h). The pattern is that USDJPY/AUDJPY/NZDJPY/CADJPY hold quadruple/triple big-miss unanimity across the first three windows, but the European-currency JPY-crosses (EURJPY, CHFJPY) break by one print at 15m/30m — the safe-haven flip on European-currency base legs is less clean, likely because EUR and CHF are themselves safe-haven-adjacent and the JPY vs EUR/CHF competitive flight is muddier. GBPJPY should close the 4-pair “full big-miss unanimity” set. Two family-closer posts remain after this one.
Verification note
All numbers verified against live /api/v1/news-impact/stats and /api/v1/news-impact/releases on 2026-09-08 across all 6 stats windows (1m/5m/15m/30m/1h/4h). Chart generated via the standard pnpm insights:chartCLI. Sample: 61 non-contaminated Japan Prelim GDP q/q releases (the 2 fewer than NZDJPY’s 63 reflect two additional pre-2010 CADJPY prints that were flagged contaminated in the anti-window). Big_miss n=4 and big_beat n=5 are both FAR below the tool’s MIN_N=30 chart threshold and drawn faint — treat this as a small-sample tail-unanimity finding, not a wide-sample effect-size claim. Coin-flip null probability of 4-of-4 DOWN at any single window is (1/2)⁴ = 6.25%; three consecutive windows with matching membership is not independent (adjacent windows share 85-95% directional signal) but the 12-of-12 zero-flip pattern across 15m/30m/1h and the exact 4-print reproduction of the USDJPY/AUDJPY/NZDJPY big-miss membership are what make the family-pattern claim strong.